Out-of-Network Therapy, Explained: Superbills, Reimbursement, and the Real Cost

Out-of-Network Therapy, Explained

Fees and health insurance can sometimes feel like taboo topics in therapist-client relationships. As a clinician, discussing money can make it feel like financial constraints get in the way of providing care, building a meaningful connection, or nurturing the therapeutic bond. However, therapy is not only an emotional and cognitive commitment—it is a financial one as well.  

Years ago, before online platforms and client portals, sessions were typically paid out of pocket using cash or checks, with no insurance coverage available. While mental health coverage in modern health insurance plans has come a long way, there is still room for improvement. Today, many therapists choose to be paneled with insurance companies to be officially approved as an in-network provider to maximize coverage for their clients, while others opt to practice out-of-network.  

The decision to remain out-of-network involves several considerations for both clinician and client, including the use of superbills. A superbill is a detailed receipt of sessions provided to clients—typically on a monthly basis—that the client themselves may submit to their insurance provider for potential reimbursement. Clients are responsible for their own submissions of their superbills to their insurance provider for out-of-network clinicians. Superbills include provider information such as the National Provider Identifier (NPI), license number, tax ID, and contact details. They also contain client information, including diagnostic codes, treatment codes, dates of service, and, if the client is a minor, the responsible party for payment. 

Reimbursement amounts depend entirely on the client’s specific out-of-network mental health benefits. During initial consultation calls, practices usually inform prospective clients whether they accept insurance directly or function as an out-of-network provider that supplies superbills.  Out-of-network clinicians may encourage prospective clients to reach out to their insurance providers prior to starting therapy to verify their out-of-network reimbursement rates.  

Paying out-of-network or out-of-pocket can certainly be a privilege that not every individual or family has access to. However, it also allows private practitioners to provide care with fewer administrative constraints or treatment constraints based on insurance needs. 

Additionally, clients choose out-of-network providers for a variety of personal reasons. Some prefer not to submit superbills at all to not have diagnostic records attached to their permanent medical histories. While submitting their super bills or not, others wish to utilize funds from HSA or FSA accounts.  

Most importantly, many individuals simply want to work with a therapist they deeply trust and connect with, regardless of network status. This highlights the vital importance of therapeutic rapport: finding a therapist with whom you feel safe, understood, and comfortable is often the single most essential part of effective care. 

Support is available—please do not hesitate to reach out and find the right fit for your journey!

By Mia Rosenthal, LCPC and owner of MiLi Counseling, PLLC

Scroll to Top